How AI Overviews change click-through rates by position
Theo Wood · 12 November, 2026 · 1 min read
In short: When an AI Overview sits above the blue links, organic CTR compresses unevenly by intent. Position 1 is no longer a complete KPI.
What changed on the SERP
For years, organic click-through followed a steep curve: position one captured a disproportionate share, then decay accelerated through the rest of page one. AI Overviews insert an answer layer above that list. The blue links still exist, but the first decision a searcher makes is often whether the generative block is “enough.”
That is not a uniform tax on every query. Overview presence clusters by intent, and the CTR compression that follows is likewise uneven. If you only watch average position, you will miss the story.
The rewritten click curve
In our informational sample, median CTR at position one nearly halved when an Overview was present. Positions two and three also lost share, while deeper results sometimes gained slightly as users scrolled past the generative block looking for alternatives.
Practically: “we still rank #1” is no longer a complete KPI. Pair ranking with Overview exposure rate, and segment CTR by Overview present vs absent before you declare a content win or loss.
Intent still decides the damage
Overviews appear most often on informational queries, which is also where click curves compress hardest. Commercial-investigational queries see Overviews less often, and when they do, users still click for comparison, pricing, and reviews.
What to do about it
- Instrument Overview presence as a SERP feature in your rank tracker, not as a footnote.
- Rebuild CTR baselines for informational clusters with and without Overviews.
- Ship citation-ready pages: concise answers near the top, then evidence, methodology, and update stamps.
- Protect commercial journeys with comparison tables, unique data, and schema that machines can quote accurately.
AI Overviews did not kill SEO. They changed the unit of competition from “best blue link” to “best answerable source.” Measure accordingly.
Share this insight
Pass it to a teammate who lives in Search Console.
Get the next insight
Occasional updates on SEO and AI search: charts first, no fluff.
We only use your email for updates. Privacy policy.